How Do You Define ‘Lesbian’?

“We are everywhere.” True or False?


Published:

Gillian Kendall

When I was in my thirties, I got embroiled in a cyber-argument with someone on a gay bulletin board about her self-definition as a lesbian. I was a newly minted lesbian myself, and I’d gone through a lot in coming out (falling in love with a woman who was not available; telling my parents, siblings, and friends about my new orientation; and being physically attacked by my male fiancée when I broke up with him). So I was self-righteously indignant that this other woman, whom I’ll call T., dared to define herself as a lesbian when she was still (horrors!) married to a man.

 

I never met T. but we exchanged some heartfelt, unpleasant emails. At one point she cited the cliché “We are everywhere” to support her claim to dykehood, and I was furious. I restrained myself from snapping back, “We are a lot of places, but we are not in heterosexual marriages, and you are not one of us.” What a sense of superiority I clung to, and what a jerk I was.

 

Last month, at age 55, I met a woman at a lesbian conference who mentioned, after we’d been talking for an hour or so, that she is not in a lesbian relationship because she’s married to a man. For reasons that had little to do with her sexual orientation, but a lot to do with her integrity, she is staying married to that man, at the same time that she’s exploring her “lesbian” identity at places like that conference. I didn’t cringe or even consider criticizing her. In fact, I was reminded of my own coming-out, when I felt stuck in a long-term relationship with a man whom I knew that I shouldn’t marry. I got out, but it took me about six months to do it and a lot of courage.The woman I met at the conference, too, will do what's right for her.

 

I got out of my het relationship calling myself “bisexual,” and only after I finally secured a girlfriend did I start applying the L-word to myself. Then I defined “lesbian” as a woman who has a romantic relationship with another woman. For me in my thirties, it didn’t count if I just wanted to have such a relationship: that didn’t confer real lesbian status. I was a lesbian wannabe, I thought, until I managed to get a girlfriend.

 

That narrow thinking led to my being in a relationship with another woman (I’ll call her S.) who also was eager, for reasons of self-definition, to be with a woman. I don’t think it was a relationship that would have happened organically, without both of our needs to act on our lesbian intentions. She and I had little in common except sexual attraction and a desire to prove that we were real lesbians. It wasn’t the worst relationship of my life, but I wish I’d been less anxious to earn my lesbian credentials and had waited to meet someone more suitable.

 

I approve of the change in myself. As a middle-aged woman and a long-lived lesbian, I’m more tolerant (read: nicer) than my younger, less secure self.

 

 

I was in one committed relationship (with one woman) for most of the intervening twenty years, and was proud to call myself lesbian, but at one point I went from the term ‘lesbian’ to ‘bi,’ when I went back to an old boyfriend. This seems a little specious: am I only bisexual when I’m with a man?

 

What I’ve learnt in more than two decades is that I can’t define anyone else’s orientation, and my own lesbian identity seems less rigid than it once was. Even without such iron-clad understanding of the term, though, I’m proud to be a lesbian.

 

I wonder if other LLLs, and younger lesbians too, feel the need even to define the term “lesbian” anymore. Are you a lesbian if you sleep with a guy once in a lifetime, or once a week? Can a lesbian be married to a man? I’d love to know how other women have defined the word that unites us, and how we are defining it now.

We love to hear from you long-lived lesbians (and others, too). Please comment below or email us at curveseniors@gmail.com

Edit ModuleEdit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Related Articles

India Just Appointed Its First Transgender Judge

But Joyita Mondal’s fight is far from over.

Celebrity Cruises Now Offers Same-Sex Marriages

They’re the first cruise line in the world to offer legalised same-sex marriages at sea.

LA Web Series Season Two Alert

We’ve been hooked on Season One, now Season Two could be in the works.

Hayley Kiyoko Brings All The Girls To The Yard

The singer’s tribute to her lesbian fans goes viral.

Add your comment: